Car Buyer Labs

Car Buying Advice, Tips, and Reviews

A red 2015 Chevy Colorado, black 2015 Chevy Silverado HD, and red 2015 Chevy Silverado 1500 are shown parked side by side in an open field with mountains in the background.

The Silverado 1500 & Colorado: Which Chevy Truck Works Best for You?

For well over a century, the pickup truck has been the ultimate symbol of capability and hard work while also being a cornerstone of Americana. Of all the brands that people have placed their trust in to provide unsurpassed excellence, look no further than Chevrolet. While there are plenty of used trucks for sale, more and more people trust Chevy to accomplish the tasks that present themselves with difficulty and establish a foundation to build a future. The two trucks that many build these foundations upon are the Silverado 1500 and Colorado. Rugged and independent, both offer advantages and prowess to those who need it. But which one works best for you? Today, we’ll examine both in order to provide a way for you to make an informed decision.

Humble Beginnings

Both the Chevy Silverado 1500 and Colorado are still relatively young vehicles, and in a short amount of time, they both have quickly established a reputation for being the very best at what they do. The Silverado 1500 debuted in 1999 and immediately set out to compete against the Ford F-150, which it’s done year after year. The Chevy Colorado, on the other hand, first came out in 2003 as the successor of the popular Chevy S-10. Smaller in scale but big on capability, the Colorado has outclassed its chief rival, the Ford Ranger.

A black 2020 Chevy Colorado ZR2, one of many used trucks for sale, is shown driving off-road in dirt.

Performance and Practicality

Depending on what you’re looking for in terms of a pickup truck, the powertrain is always a great place to start. Both vehicles are equipped with effective engines and come in a variety of trims to adhere to whatever your needs might be. The Colorado is the smaller of the two vehicles, so we’ll start with what it has to offer you in the performance section.

What makes the Colorado such a unique, smaller-sized truck is the fact that it can handle everything from the job site to journeying off of the pavement, depending upon which trim you select. Chevy equips the Colorado with a sole powertrain in the form of a 2.7L four-cylinder engine that works in conjunction with an eight-speed automatic transmission. However, that one engine has three different configurations delivering varying levels of power. The base trims, which are perfectly suited for the workplace or a daily commute, have the benefit of 237 horsepower. For those who are adamant about taking the path less traveled and enjoying the world of off-roading, the ZR2 package with the high-output engine ups performance to 310 horsepower and possesses over ten inches of ground clearance, making it able to adapt to any off-roading situation.

The Silverado 1500, long hailed as the flagship vehicle for the Chevy fleet, provides a variety of optional powertrains that are excellent for a variety of purposes. For the daily driver who places practicality as their top priority, the base offering consists of a turbocharged four-cylinder engine with 310 horsepower. Much like the Colorado, this engine is matched with an eight-speed automatic transmission to provide a smooth ride, no matter where the road takes you.

An advantage that the Silverado possesses over the smaller-sized Colorado is the option of a diesel-fueled powertrain. The 3.0L turbocharged Duramax engine has been earning its stripes and reputation for a while. It offers 305 horsepower and the capability to generate 495 lb-ft of torque, making it perfect for the average towing enthusiast. For those who have the need to go big or go home, the Silverado can also be outfitted with one of two distinctive V8 options––a 5.3L or a 6.2L. The latter of these two engines propels the Silverado towards any desired goal with the benefit of 420 horsepower.

Towing and Trailering

A common activity with pickup truck owners is that whether they’re on the pavement or journeying off of it, trailering and towing capability is certainly one that many are in need of. As a credit to the brand’s dedication to surpassing its competitors, the Chevy Colorado has the highest tow rating in its class, which is up to 7,700 lbs. This outclasses the Ford Ranger, Jeep Gladiator, Honda Ridgeline, and Toyota Tacoma. Capability is the name that’s most synonymous with the Colorado, and this specification certainly proves that.

For those who need to maximize their towing options, the Silverado 1500 proves its raw power and versatility as one of the best towing machines in the entire industry. The base engine has a substantial amount of prowess with a maximum rating of 9,500 lbs. That said, both V8 powertrains are best suited for those who have a need to move mountains. The 5.3L can pull up to 11,300 lbs with minimal difficulty, and the 6.2L possesses the Silverado’s maximum towing capacity of 13,300. This outclasses the Ram 1500 by over 500 lbs, which certainly goes to show the ability that the Silverado is world-renowned for.

The interior of the 2018 Chevy Silverado 1500 is shown with brown leather seats from the perspective of the second row.

Fuel Economy

With fuel prices always being a great concern to the average consumer, conservative fuel consumption is an important aspect to look at in a truck. The Colorado, with its capable four-cylinder, allows consumers to achieve 20 MPG in the city and 25 MPG on the highway. Drivers who are looking to purchase a Silverado 1500 but maximize the distance between fill-ups are encouraged to take advantage of the diesel engine. The Duramax allows the Silverado to obtain 24 MPG in the city and 29 MPG on the highway.

Interior and Comfort

While performance specs are certainly attractive to prospective truck drivers, it’s the interior of the vehicle where you’ll be spending a considerable amount of time. As a result, it’s important that you have the comforts of home at your disposal. The Silverado 1500, with its wood-colored trim, has the sort of rustic feel that the discerning outdoorsman will certainly enjoy. Spacious and roomy, Chevy makes the most of what they’re working with to make a comfortable experience, even when the road ahead might not be.

The Chevy Colorado, on the other hand, has a unique interior that has a more modern appeal when it comes to placement and style. With its infotainment screen that stretches out to 11.3 inches and digital instrument panel, the Colorado has all the trapping of a modern truck for today’s driver. The interiors of both vehicles are certainly exquisite and will appeal to anyone who sits behind the wheel.

Determining the Right Choice

So, how do you choose between the Silverado and Colorado? Both are highly capable vehicles that are built to perform beyond expectation. So, how do you choose? How do you pinpoint which vehicle is perfectly suited for your needs? The fact of the matter is it all depends upon what your immediate needs might be.

For the off-roader and daily commuter, the Colorado is certainly the ideal choice. With the best towing capacity in its class, you’ll be able to bring along an ATV or two en route to your next adventure. For the driver who has a need to move mountains, the Silverado 1500 is the perfect accessory for the job site and can accommodate driving during your day-to-day commute with ease. Now, all you have to do is decide which one you need.